Puerto Rico: Editor Picks

Looking for the best places to eat, sleep, shop, and socialize in the most accessible U.S. destination in the Caribbean? Let our Editor Picks, hand-selected by Sherman's staff of expert editors, guide you to Puerto Rico’s dazzling natural wonders (bioluminescent bays, spectacular caves), its unique and cozy hotels (El Convento), and its underrated historical gems (San Juan National Historic Site).

= Smart Splurge = Great Value

Bioluminescent Bays When it’s pitch dark, paddle out to one of these bioluminescent inlets (in Fajardo, Parguera, and Vieques – though Vieques is said to have the best one in the world) and jump into the water. Your entire body will glow, caused by the defense mechanism of the dinoflagellates that swim in the water. Vieques; www.gotopuertorico.com/puerto-rico-bio-bays.php
family | things to do | outdoors | adventure

East, West, Sugarcane, and Pineapple courses The Hyatt hotels are closed, but the four golf courses by Robert Trent Jones, Sr. are still the most beloved on the island. Hit a lousy shot and you might have to pay for Chi Chi Rodriguez’ window – in other words, he has a home there. 100 Dorado Beach Dr.; 787-796-1234; www.doradobeachclubs.com
golf | smart splurge | sports | golf course

El Conquistador Puerto Rico’s grande dame, this Fajardo resort near El Yunque sprawls atop a bluff and offers guests access to its Golden Door Spa, a nearby private island, and a golf course. Av El Conquistador; 787-863-6784; www.elconresort.com
luxury | golf | family | hotel | smart splurge | expensive

El Conquistador course The El Con’s course is known for steep climbs and breathtaking views of the ocean and rainforest. Av El Conquistador; 787-863-6784; www.elconresort.com
golf | smart splurge | view | sports | golf course

El Convento This 17th-century convent in Old San Juan was reborn as a luxury hotel and is now your best choice for a taste of old Puerto Rico. Old San Juan; 100 Cristo St.; 787-723-9020; www.elconvento.com
hotel | moderate | historic | great value

El Yunque The 28,000-acre preserve is almost as much mountain as it is rainforest, so get ready for some serious hiking. You’ll hear the Coqui (pronounced co-KEE), a tree frog named after its squeaking mating call. Rio Grande; www.fs.fed.us/r8/Caribbean
family | hiking | wildlife | things to do | outdoors

Museo De Arte Puerto Rico The elegant, comprehensive museum is worth the drive to the west side of the city, but a meal at Pikayo, Wylie Benet’s on-site restaurant, will show diners all that Criollo (Spanish for Creole) cuisine can be. Santurce; Ave. de Diego 299; www.mapr.org
culture | culinary | smart splurge | things to do | art

Rio Camuy Caves Ride a trolley into these majestic caves, carved out eons ago by the Rio Camuy River, which still runs through them. The sound-of-body can sign up for spelunking trips through eco-tour operators; the weak-of-heart will be more than impressed with the trolley tour. The total number of visitors each day is limited, so book early. 787-898-3100; www.gotopuertorico.com/puerto-rico-camuy-cavern.php
tour | things to do | adventure

San Juan National Historic Site Explore the vestiges of El Morro and San Cristobal, two massive forts dating from 1539 – and used by the U.S. army until 1951 – at this protected Old San Juan site. Old San Juan; www.nps.gov/saju
family | architecture | culture | things to do | history